Skip to content 
The moment you see flashing lights in your rearview mirror, a wave of fear can wash over you. For a parent, that fear isn't just about a ticket or a fine; it's a gut-wrenching dread about what comes next. How will this affect your kids? Your job? Your ability to hold your family together? A DWI charge can feel like your entire world is on the verge of collapsing. But it's crucial to remember that this is the beginning of a legal process, not the end of your story. Your most critical moves in the first 24 hours—invoking your right to remain silent and calling an experienced DWI defense attorney—can dramatically change the course of your case.
Your First Steps After a Texas DWI Charge
The moments after an arrest are disorienting and terrifying. The dread isn't just about potential jail time or fines; it’s about your children, your job, and your ability to keep everything afloat. A DWI charge can feel like the world is crumbling, but it's vital to remember this is just the start of a legal process, not a final judgment. Your actions in the immediate aftermath are the foundation of your defense. The goal is to replace panic with a clear, deliberate plan.
A Relatable Scenario: The Wrong Moves
Imagine you’re driving home from dinner with friends where you had two glasses of wine over a couple of hours. You feel perfectly fine, but an officer pulls you over for not coming to a complete stop. He asks if you've been drinking. Wanting to be cooperative, you say, "Just a couple with dinner." That statement, meant to be harmless, just became evidence against you.
Feeling the pressure, you agree to do Field Sobriety Tests on an uneven patch of roadside. You're nervous, so you stumble. Now you're in handcuffs. At the station, feeling defeated, you answer more questions and agree to a breathalyzer. You’ve just helped the prosecution build its case without even realizing it. This is a perfect example of how easily a parent, trying to do the right thing, can accidentally harm their own defense.
What to Do Instead: Protect Your Rights
The single most powerful tool you have during a DWI stop is your constitutional right to remain silent. You are only required to provide your name, driver's license, and proof of insurance. That's it.
Beyond that, you can—and should—state clearly and politely:
"Officer, I am exercising my right to remain silent. I will not answer any questions without my attorney present."
This one sentence is your shield. It prevents you from accidentally giving the police incriminating information. It's not an admission of guilt; it's a fundamental right that keeps you from becoming the star witness against yourself. This is an actionable step you can take to protect your family's future from the very start.
Texas prosecutes DWI cases aggressively. In 2023, alcohol-impaired driving fatalities accounted for 40 percent of Texas's total motor vehicle fatalities—the second-highest rate in the nation. This zero-tolerance approach is detailed in the FY 2025 Texas Impaired Driving Plan, underscoring why getting strong legal help from the very beginning is non-negotiable.
Why Your First Call Matters
After you invoke your right to silence, your first and only call should be to a skilled DWI defense attorney. An experienced lawyer can jump in immediately to protect your interests, advise you on chemical tests, and start preparing for the critical steps ahead. Even a first offense DWI in Texas comes with serious penalties, including jail time and a suspended license.
An attorney can:
- Advise you on whether to consent to a breath or blood test.
- Start gathering evidence while it’s still fresh.
- Prepare to fight for your driver's license in the Administrative License Revocation (ALR) hearing.
Getting these initial steps right sets the stage for a strong defense. You don't have to navigate this frightening time alone. The compassionate and experienced attorneys at The Law Office of Bryan Fagan are here to guide you with understanding and strength.
Challenging the Initial Traffic Stop
Every DWI case in Texas starts with a traffic stop. This first interaction is the bedrock of the entire case against you. If that bedrock is shaky—if the officer lacked a legitimate, legal reason to pull you over—everything that followed can be challenged and potentially thrown out of court. For any parent facing this, scrutinizing the legality of that initial stop is a crucial first step in fighting for your family’s future. The law is clear: an officer must have reasonable suspicion that you've broken a traffic law or are involved in criminal activity. This isn’t a gut feeling; it must be based on specific, observable facts.
The Standard for a Lawful Stop
Reasonable suspicion is a lower bar than probable cause, but it’s still more than a whim. An officer must be able to point to exactly what they saw that made them believe you had violated a law.
Some of the most common valid reasons include:
- Moving Violations: Speeding, not using a turn signal, running a red light, or weaving across lane lines.
- Equipment Violations: A broken headlight, an expired registration sticker, or illegally dark window tint.
- Erratic Driving: Behavior suggesting impairment, like driving excessively slow, braking without reason, or making unusually wide turns.
If the officer cannot name a specific, legitimate violation, the stop may be unlawful. This is often the first—and most effective—place to build a powerful defense.
A Scenario Unfolding
Imagine you're driving home late one Saturday night. An officer pulls you over and tells you that you were "drifting within your lane." You know you never crossed the lines, just made small corrections. This is a textbook example of a weak reason for a stop. A good DWI attorney would immediately question whether that's even a real traffic violation under Texas law.
From there, the situation can escalate. The officer might say they smell alcohol and ask you to get out of the car. Just like that, a flimsy stop turns into a full-blown DWI investigation. Your lawyer’s first move would be to scrutinize the dashcam and bodycam footage. Did your driving truly give the officer a valid reason to pull you over? If not, a motion to suppress evidence is the next step.
What is a Motion to Suppress?
A motion to suppress is a formal request to the court to exclude evidence that was obtained illegally. If the traffic stop itself was unlawful, then all the evidence that came after—the officer's observations, your statements, field sobriety test results, and any breath or blood tests—is considered "fruit of the poisonous tree." The court may rule that none of it can be used against you.
Law enforcement often ramps up patrols during specific times. In 2024, Texas recorded 1,053 deaths from DUI-related crashes, with a huge number of these incidents happening between 2 a.m. and 3 a.m. on weekends. This heightened alert can sometimes lead to officers making stops based on very thin pretexts. Understanding these patterns, which you can see in the official Texas traffic safety data, can be a key part of building your defense strategy.
From Reasonable Suspicion to Probable Cause
Once you're pulled over, the legal standard for actually arresting you gets higher. To make a DWI arrest, the officer now needs probable cause—a reasonable belief, backed by facts and circumstances, that you were driving while intoxicated.
This is where their observations and any tests they conduct come into play. They’ll be looking for things like:
- The smell of alcohol
- Slurred speech or bloodshot eyes
- Any admission of drinking
- How you perform on Field Sobriety Tests
A skilled attorney's job is to pick apart every one of these elements. Was the officer's report an exaggeration? Could a medical condition, or just nerves, have affected your speech and balance? By challenging the officer's justification for both the initial stop and the eventual arrest, a strong defense team can dismantle the prosecution's case from the very beginning. Your family’s stability is too important to leave to chance.
Challenging Field Sobriety and Chemical Test Results
For most families in Texas, the scariest part of a DWI stop isn't getting pulled over—it's the battery of tests that follows. The prosecutor's entire case often hinges on the results of so-called Field Sobriety Tests (FSTs) and the numbers from a breathalyzer or blood draw. These tests are designed to look scientific and foolproof, but they are anything but. Digging into the built-in weaknesses and strict procedural rules for this evidence is a cornerstone of any solid DWI defense. An arrest built on a shaky foundation of faulty or misinterpreted tests can absolutely be challenged, giving your family a real chance to move forward.
The Truth About Field Sobriety Tests
When an officer suspects you’ve been drinking, they'll usually roll out a series of three Standardized Field Sobriety Tests (SFSTs). These aren't pass/fail exams. They are divided-attention tasks meant to see if you can follow complex instructions while performing awkward physical movements. The biggest problem? A hundred things besides alcohol can make a completely sober person "fail."
The three tests you'll likely encounter are:
- The Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) Test: The officer watches for an involuntary jerking motion in your eyes as you follow their finger or a penlight.
- The Walk-and-Turn Test: You’re told to take nine steps, heel-to-toe, down a real or imaginary line, pivot, and walk back nine steps.
- The One-Leg Stand Test: You have to stand on one foot, raise the other about six inches off the ground, and count out loud to 30.
These tests are notoriously subjective. The officer is looking for specific "clues," and their judgment can be clouded by the fact they've already decided you might be intoxicated.
How a Real-World Scenario Exposes the Flaws
Picture this: you've spent the entire day chasing your kids around the park. You're exhausted. You have an old knee injury that acts up when you're tired. On the drive home, you see the flashing lights. The officer asks you to perform the One-Leg Stand test on the side of a dark, slightly sloped road, with cars whizzing past.
You're nervous, your knee is stiff, and you’re just plain tired. You put your foot down once to catch your balance. To the officer, that's a checkmark in the "intoxicated" column. To you, it's just reality. This is a perfect example of how easily external factors can wreck FST results:
- Medical Conditions: Bad knees, inner ear problems, back injuries, or even neurological issues can make it impossible to perform these tests correctly.
- Environmental Factors: Poor lighting, an uneven surface, or cold weather can throw anyone off balance.
- Personal Factors: Your age, weight, fatigue, and even the shoes you're wearing can dramatically affect your performance.
- Nervousness: Just being anxious about the situation is enough to make anyone a bit shaky.
A sharp defense attorney will get that dashcam video and scrutinize every second of it. We look to see if the officer followed the standardized procedures to the letter and whether the conditions were remotely fair. Any deviation can be grounds to get those results thrown out.
Unpacking the Weaknesses in Chemical Tests
After the roadside gymnastics, you’ll probably be asked for a chemical test—a breathalyzer or a blood draw—to measure your Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC). While these feel more scientific, they are also riddled with potential errors.
A number spit out by a machine doesn't automatically mean you're guilty. The reliability of chemical test evidence is only as good as the procedures used to get it, and there are countless points where things can go wrong.
A breathalyzer's accuracy hangs on a lot of "ifs." The machine itself, often an Intoxilyzer 9000 here in Texas, has to be properly calibrated and maintained. If the logs show it hasn't been, the readings can be unreliable. On top of that, everyday things like mouthwash, acid reflux, or even certain low-carb diets can trigger a false positive.
Blood tests are generally seen as more accurate, but they come with their own set of landmines, primarily the chain of custody. For a blood test result to hold up in court, the prosecutor has to prove, without a doubt, that the sample was handled correctly at every single step. Any gap or mistake in this chain can contaminate the sample or make the results completely unreliable.
An experienced DWI lawyer will immediately demand and review every piece of paper related to that chemical test. Finding procedural errors is one of the most powerful ways to get unreliable evidence excluded from your case. You have the right to challenge every piece of evidence, and at The Law Office of Bryan Fagan, we know exactly where to find the weak spots in the prosecution's argument.
Here's a look at how we break down the evidence the state relies on.
Common Defenses Against DWI Test Evidence
This table highlights common vulnerabilities in the prosecution's evidence and the corresponding legal defense strategies used to challenge them in a Texas DWI case.
| Type of Evidence | Common Weaknesses | Potential Defense Strategy |
|---|---|---|
| Field Sobriety Tests | Officer's subjective scoring, improper instructions, unfair testing conditions (e.g., uneven ground, poor lighting), and the person's physical or medical limitations. | File a Motion to Suppress, arguing the tests were not administered according to NHTSA standards. Use dashcam footage to show unfair conditions or incorrect procedures. |
| Breathalyzer Test | Improper machine calibration, failure to observe the 15-minute waiting period, interference from medical conditions (like GERD), or environmental contaminants. | Subpoena maintenance and calibration logs for the breathalyzer machine. Introduce expert testimony on factors that can create false positives. |
| Blood Test | Break in the chain of custody, improper storage of the sample (fermentation), contamination during the draw or analysis, and unqualified personnel handling the sample. | Demand and scrutinize all chain of custody documentation. Challenge the qualifications of the phlebotomist or lab technician. Argue for suppression due to procedural errors. |
| Officer Testimony | Inconsistent statements, biased observations, and failure to follow established police procedures during the stop, investigation, or arrest. | Cross-examine the officer at trial to highlight inconsistencies between their report, testimony, and the video evidence. Challenge the initial reason for the traffic stop. |
Knowing where to look for these weaknesses is half the battle. A thorough defense means leaving no stone unturned and questioning every assumption the prosecution makes.
Protecting Your Driver's License at the ALR Hearing
After a Texas DWI arrest, you’re suddenly fighting a war on two fronts. Beyond the criminal charges looming over you, there's an immediate, time-sensitive battle to save your driver's license. This is a separate civil process called the Administrative License Revocation (ALR) hearing, and you have a razor-thin window to act: just 15 days from the date of your arrest to formally request it.
Miss that deadline, and your license is likely gone—suspended automatically. For any parent who relies on their car for school runs, errands, and just getting to work, losing the ability to drive can instantly turn a bad situation into a full-blown family crisis. This is an actionable step that cannot be missed.
Why the ALR Hearing Is More Than Just a Formality
It’s easy to write off the ALR hearing as a minor bureaucratic hurdle compared to the criminal case, but that’s a huge mistake. This isn't just your only shot to stop an administrative license suspension; it's also one of the most powerful strategic tools you have for your criminal defense.
Think of it as a free, early look at the prosecutor's playbook. The ALR hearing is an invaluable chance for your attorney to question the arresting officer under oath, long before you ever see the inside of a criminal courtroom. This is your first—and sometimes best—opportunity to scrutinize the state's evidence.
Your lawyer can use this hearing to:
- Lock in the officer's testimony: Everything the officer says is recorded. If their story changes later in criminal court, their credibility can be seriously undermined.
- Uncover weaknesses in the case: This is where your attorney can dig for inconsistencies in the police report, find procedural mistakes made during the traffic stop, or identify problems with how the field sobriety tests were administered.
- Gather critical evidence: The sworn testimony and documents produced for the ALR hearing can become powerful leverage for negotiating with the prosecutor or for dismantling their case at trial.
Essentially, you get a "dry run" at cross-examining the state's key witness. For your overall defense strategy, that can be a complete game-changer.
Navigating the ALR Process Step-by-Step
Requesting the hearing is the first critical step. The request has to be filed with the Texas Department of Public Safety (DPS) within that strict 15-day timeframe. A seasoned DWI attorney makes this their first priority to ensure you don't miss the deadline.
Once the hearing is requested, it gets scheduled before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ). The judge is only there to decide one thing: whether DPS has enough evidence to suspend your license. The state's attorney has to prove two key points:
- The officer had reasonable suspicion for the initial stop and probable cause to arrest you.
- You either refused to provide a breath or blood sample, or you provided one that showed a BAC of 0.08% or higher.
This infographic lays out the typical sequence of events that can land you in an ALR hearing if you refuse or fail the chemical tests.
As you can see, every stage—from the roadside exercises to the stationhouse chemical tests—is a point where procedural errors can happen. Each one creates an opportunity for your lawyer to challenge the license suspension.
For a parent facing a DWI, the ALR hearing is your first line of defense in keeping your family's life on track. Winning this hearing doesn't just save your license; it sends a clear signal to the prosecutor that you are ready and willing to fight every part of their case.
Even if you don't win the ALR hearing, the battle isn't over. The information you gain is priceless for your criminal defense. And if your license is suspended, your attorney can immediately help you apply for an occupational driver's license, which allows you to drive to essential places like work, school, and your kids' appointments. The clock starts ticking the second you're arrested. Don't let this critical 15-day window slam shut.
Building Your DWI Defense Strategy for Court
A winning DWI defense in Texas is rarely about a single, dramatic “gotcha” moment in the courtroom. A strong defense is built by methodically taking the prosecutor's case apart, piece by piece, until all that’s left is reasonable doubt. This is where all our hard work—challenging the traffic stop, questioning the field sobriety tests, and fighting for your license—comes together in a cohesive strategy to protect your family's future. The entire burden of proof rests on the state. It is not your job to prove you were sober. The prosecutor has to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, that you were intoxicated. Our job is to show the judge and jury that they simply cannot meet that incredibly high standard.
Scrutinizing Every Piece of Evidence
The first thing your attorney must do is become an expert on every single detail of your case. That means getting our hands on every piece of evidence the state plans to use against you and analyzing it with a fine-tooth comb.
- Police Reports: We're not just reading for what’s there, but for what’s not there. Vague descriptions, contradictory statements, or generic "boilerplate" language can be a huge red flag that signals a weak case.
- Dashcam and Bodycam Footage: Video is often the most honest witness in the room. We watch it frame-by-frame, comparing what the officer wrote in the report to what actually happened on the side of the road.
- Lab Results and Maintenance Logs: When it comes to breath or blood tests, the paper trail is everything. We scrutinize the calibration records for the machine, the chain of custody documents, and lab procedures for any misstep that could make the results completely unreliable.
Finding these cracks and inconsistencies is how we begin to build a foundation of reasonable doubt.
Developing Specific Defense Angles
Once we’ve thoroughly reviewed all the evidence, specific defense theories start to take shape. While every case is unique, several common angles can be incredibly effective.
One of the most powerful is the "Rising BAC" defense. This argument doesn't necessarily dispute the number on the chemical test result; instead, it challenges when you reached that level of intoxication.
Think about this common scenario: you have a drink or two with dinner and start driving home a short time later. At the moment you were behind the wheel, your Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) was still well below the legal limit of 0.08%. But alcohol isn't absorbed instantly. By the time you're pulled over, arrested, taken to the station, and finally given a breath or blood test an hour or more later, your BAC has continued to climb, peaking above the legal limit while you were in police custody—not while you were driving.
In Texas, the state has to prove you were intoxicated at the time you were operating a motor vehicle. If we can show your BAC was likely legal while driving and only rose above the limit later, the prosecution’s entire case can fall apart.
Understanding the Stakes and the Landscape
Fighting a DWI in Texas means you’re going up against an aggressive prosecution machine. The state's own statistics show just how serious they are about enforcement. With 316.94 DUI arrests per 100,000 drivers, and cities like Houston and Dallas ranking among the worst in the nation for drunk driving incidents, prosecutors pursue these cases with everything they've got. This is why a cookie-cutter defense won't work. The potential consequences go far beyond the criminal case, too, with civil liabilities that can include things like multi-million dollar jury awards in DWI rollover crashes. We must be prepared to challenge every shred of the state's evidence.
Pathways to a Positive Outcome
A strong, well-prepared defense opens up several different paths to a favorable resolution. The ultimate goal is always to get the best possible outcome for your specific situation.
These pathways often include:
- Negotiating a Dismissal or Reduced Charge: When your attorney presents compelling evidence of weaknesses in the case, a prosecutor is often far more willing to negotiate. Our guide on how to get criminal charges dropped offers more insight into how this works.
- Filing a Motion to Suppress Evidence: If key evidence was obtained illegally, we can ask the judge to throw it out. If the motion is granted, it often guts the prosecutor's case and leads to a dismissal.
- Going to Trial for an Acquittal: Sometimes the prosecution refuses to offer a fair deal. In those moments, a skilled trial attorney needs to be ready to present your defense to a jury and fight for a "not guilty" verdict.
A DWI charge feels overwhelming, but remember, you have rights and options. The difference between facing this alone and having an experienced legal advocate in your corner is profound.
Frequently Asked Questions About Texas DWI Cases
When you're staring down a DWI charge in Texas, your mind starts racing with questions. It’s the uncertainty that hits the hardest, especially for parents trying to keep their family's world from spinning off its axis. This section is designed to give you direct, clear answers to the questions we hear most often, cutting through the legal jargon to give you the solid information you need.
What’s the Difference Between a First and Second DWI?
The jump from a first to a second DWI in Texas is significant. The consequences get more severe, and the system is far less forgiving.
While a first-time DWI is usually a Class B misdemeanor, a second offense gets bumped up to a Class A misdemeanor. This means you’re now facing:
- Higher fines, potentially up to $4,000.
- Longer jail time, with a mandatory minimum of 30 days and up to a full year behind bars.
- A much longer driver's license suspension, lasting anywhere from 180 days to two years.
Prosecutors are much less likely to offer a favorable plea deal when they see a prior offense. This makes a strategic, aggressive defense absolutely critical from day one.
Can I Get My DWI Charge Reduced to Something Else?
Yes, it is possible, but it requires a skilled legal strategy. Your attorney can negotiate with the prosecutor to get the charge lowered to something like Obstruction of a Highway or Reckless Driving. These lesser charges don't carry the same heavy baggage as a DWI conviction. You can often avoid the mandatory license suspensions and the sky-high insurance rates that come with a DWI. This kind of reduction is most likely to happen when your lawyer finds significant weaknesses in the state's case against you—think a faulty traffic stop, questionable field sobriety test administration, or unreliable breath or blood test results.
Do I Have to Go to Jail for a First-Time DWI?
Not necessarily. While a first-time DWI is a Class B misdemeanor that carries a potential jail sentence of 72 hours to 180 days, an experienced attorney can often negotiate alternatives. For many parents, avoiding jail is the number one priority so they can keep working and caring for their kids. We often successfully argue for options like probation (community supervision), community service, and mandatory DWI education classes instead of jail time. You can find more helpful information in our guide to understanding a Class B Misdemeanor in Texas.
The key takeaway here is that an arrest does not automatically equal jail time. A proactive, well-planned defense can open up several paths to alternative sentencing that protect your freedom and your family’s stability.
Is It Possible to Fight a DWI and Win?
Absolutely. Not only is it possible to fight a DWI charge, but it's also your constitutional right. Winning a DWI case isn't about luck; it's about a meticulous review of every piece of evidence to find procedural mistakes, constitutional violations, and factual holes in the prosecution's story. We can challenge the legality of the initial traffic stop, question the officer’s training, or dispute the scientific accuracy of the breathalyzer or blood test. A win could mean a full dismissal of the charges, a reduction to a non-DWI offense, or a "not guilty" verdict from a jury at trial.
A DWI charge can feel like you're facing an insurmountable challenge, but you do not have to go through it alone. The dedicated attorneys at The Law Office of Bryan Fagan have the experience and compassion to guide you through every step, fighting to protect your rights, your freedom, and most importantly, your family. We understand what is at stake. For a free, confidential consultation to discuss your case and learn how we can help, contact us today at https://texascpslawyer.net.
